Current
ENCORE Product Efficacy Funding Opportunity
Part of ENCORE
Audiences
Learning Environments
Explore More From This Program
Overview
We are looking to fund whole-product efficacy studies of AI-enabled math products, implemented during the 2027–28 school year.
These studies will generate efficacy signals of how using AI-enabled math products leads to learning gains, especially for students performing one to three grade levels behind in math.
Key Details
- Funding: Grant awards ranging from $200,000–$300,000 per selected team, based on study design and rigor
- RFI deadline: Jan. 8, 2027, at 11:59 p.m. PT
- Estimated grant award period: April 2027–December 2028
- How to apply: Download the RFI instructions and submit your response online
Who Should Apply
We want to hear from teams with AI-enabled K–12 math products that are ready for extended classroom implementation and evaluation. If you meet the criteria below, we encourage you to respond.
- AI-powered math product: Your product uses generative AI to improve math learning or instruction for K–12 students. The product can be either teacher- or student-facing, and should align to at least one of our AI use cases.
- Track record in schools: Your team has worked in schools with this product and has some prior evidence of its feasibility. Your team also has a strong relationship with a district partner who would want to work with you as part of the proposed efficacy study.
- Ready for testing: The whole product must be fully developed; this is not seed funding for product development. Updates already on your product roadmap may be included if they will be complete before the 2027–28 school year. You should be ready to study your product’s impact on standardized math assessments at multiple points through the 2027–28 school year.
- Research partner: You have identified a research partner you intend to work with and the activities they will lead.
- Study scale: Your partners can support a study of at least 350 students. For designs that assign schools to use the product, we expect at least eight product schools and at least as many comparison schools. Additional comparison schools drawn from existing district or state data are encouraged.
- Commitment to open results: You will pre-register your study and publicly report findings, regardless of outcome.
Priority will be given to products aligned to high-quality instructional materials (HQIM), products with prior studies of their validity, implementation, or efficacy, and teams with a letter of support from a school or district partner.
Budget
Proposals may request up to $300,000, based on study design and rigor. Award amounts will reflect the proposed budget and justification, the study design, and the depth of information the study will provide. For example:
- Up to $200,000: a historical comparison using a prior cohort of students in the same schools (for example, the previous year’s students in the same grades). Studies should also collect at least one validated leading indicator at the beginning and end of the study year, to examine how it relates to product use and student outcomes.
- Up to $300,000: a concurrent comparison group with multiple validated leading indicators collected for both groups, and a sample that goes beyond the minimum study scale (see eligibility requirements), such as additional product or comparison schools.
Studies that fall between these examples, such as a concurrent comparison group with one leading indicator, will be funded within this range. Not all proposals will be funded at the maximum amount, and funding may be adjusted during the grant making process. The RFI requires a budget estimate that includes expected costs for school or district partners and your research partner.
Teams invited to the full RFP should be prepared to provide:
- A letter of support from each school or district partner. Funded teams will be expected to execute an MOU within approximately 30 days of award notification.
- Confirmation that your research partner has agreed to work with you, pending funding, along with a quote for their work.
Questions about eligibility? Check the FAQs or email encore-product-efficacy@digitalpromise.org.
Evaluation Criteria
The primary goal of these studies is to establish whether adopting the product improves student performance and accelerates academic growth under real-world conditions, especially for students who are starting out performing one to three grade levels behind in math. Studies should also help us understand what works, for whom, and under what conditions: how results differ across student groups, how implementation and product use relate to outcomes, and how leading indicators (such as student motivation, engagement, and persistence, and teacher effectiveness) relate to student performance.
RFI stage: We will review responses for product readiness, project readiness, and preliminary study design.
- Product Readiness: The product has been used in schools and has prior evidence of its feasibility. It has a clear rationale for how its use improves learning, a documented process for reviewing the accuracy and safety of its AI outputs, and a realistic plan to complete any roadmap updates before the 2027–28 school year.
- Project Readiness: The team has experience working in schools, relationships with one or more schools or districts (a letter of support is encouraged but not required at the RFI stage), an identified research partner with a defined role, and a realistic path to approvals and data access.
- Preliminary Study Design: The team has an initial plan that meets the rigorous study requirements, including the minimum study scale, and is feasible to carry out with their partners and timeline.
Full RFP stage (invite-only): Invited teams will be evaluated in more depth on the criteria below. Applicants should expect to provide more specifics, such as named measures, power analysis with minimum detectable effect size, and secured partner commitments.
Full Proposal Criteria
Product Readiness
- Uses generative AI in at least one of the five use cases: AI Tutoring, Adaptive Practice and Feedback, Student Work Analysis and Grading, Lesson Planning, or Professional Learning and Coaching
- Developed with input from educators and/or students
- Alignment with high-quality instructional materials (HQIM)
- Stable product version throughout the 2027–28 school year: any roadmap updates are complete before the school year begins, and no new features are released during the study. Bug fixes and minor improvements are acceptable.
- A documented process to systematically review, validate, and refine the accuracy, safety, and reliability of AI-generated outputs over time
- A logic model connecting product use to student outcomes, including a hypothesis about dosage and implementation
Project Readiness
- Letter of support from each school or district partner, with an MOU to follow within approximately 30 days of award notification
- Research partner who has agreed to work with the team, pending funding, and has provided a quote. At minimum, the partner conducts the primary outcome analysis (rigor increases the more of the study an external partner leads)
- Data infrastructure to measure student outcomes and compare product use data with interim or benchmark data
- Experience conducting research in schools
- Commitment to pre-register and publish results regardless of outcome. Projects are also encouraged to contribute public goods for the field, such as openly accessible publications, presentations at convenings, or openly licensed resources like de-identified datasets, measures, or analysis code.
- Research approvals (such as IRB and district research approval) secured, or a clear plan to secure them quickly
- An implementation plan, including professional learning and support for teachers
Study Design
- No-product comparison group, in order of preference:
- A concurrent business-as-usual group, randomized or prospectively matched on prior achievement and demographics (a staggered rollout, where the comparison group starts using the product the following semester, is acceptable)
- A historical comparison using a prior cohort of students in the same schools.
- Single-group designs, including pre/post comparisons and comparisons of the same students’ fall and spring results, are not eligible.
- An extended implementation timeline: one semester minimum, full academic year preferred
- At least 350 students (and at least eight product schools and as many comparison schools for school-level designs), with a power analysis reporting the minimum detectable effect. Data must allow subgroup analysis by baseline performance, race/ethnicity, and economic status.
- Student achievement measured with independent standardized assessments at baseline and outcome for both groups
- At least one validated leading indicator (student motivation, engagement, or persistence, or teacher effectiveness), collected for both groups in concurrent designs or at the start and end of the study year in historical designs. Existing district tools may be used.
- Methods to assess potential contextual drivers (e.g., implementation fidelity, classroom environment conditions) of results.
- The primary analysis compares everyone assigned to use the product with the comparison group, regardless of how much they used it. Analyses based on usage, such as dose-response models or comparisons limited to active users, may be included but cannot serve as the primary analysis.
How We’ll Use What We Learn
Digital Promise and the Gates Foundation will review RFI responses to determine which teams to invite to participate in a closed RFP. Digital Promise will also analyze and publicly synthesize themes across responses. No proprietary information will be shared in the synthesis.
How to Apply
Product teams are invited to respond by completing the online form. We are interested in hearing from product teams who serve K–12 students and teachers and have emerging or existing research partnerships.
- Review the eligibility requirements and evaluation criteria on this page.
- Download the RFI instructions and prepare your responses offline. The online form may not save your progress, so keep a copy of your responses.
- Submit your response through the online form by Jan. 8, 2027 at 11:59 p.m. PT.
Key Dates
2026
Nov. 18, 2026: RFI opens
2027
Jan. 8, 2027: RFI responses due by 11:59 p.m. PT
Jan. 25, 2027: Selected respondents invited to submit a full proposal
Feb. 19, 2027: Full proposals due (invite-only)
February 2027: All RFI respondents receive an update
March 2027: Grantees announced
April 2027–December 2028: Estimated grant period
2027–28 School Year: Studies implemented in classrooms
Frequently Asked Questions
Where do I submit my response?
Submit through the online RFI form. We recommend downloading the PDF version of the RFI to prepare your responses first, then copying them into the form. The form may not save your progress, so keep a copy of your responses.
When will I hear back?
Selected respondents will be invited by Jan. 25, 2027, to submit a full proposal, due Feb. 19, 2027. All applicants will receive an update by February 2027.
What should I expect if I’m invited to submit a full proposal?
Applicants invited to the full RFP will build on their RFI with more detail. Invited teams will receive full instructions, but should be prepared to provide:
- A logic model connecting product use to student outcomes, with a hypothesis about dosage and implementation
- A detailed study design, including the comparison group, sample, power analysis, and timeline
- Student achievement and leading indicator measures, with validation evidence
- A data analysis plan, including subgroup analyses and how product use data will be linked to outcomes
- A letter of support from each school or district partner and the status of research approvals and data agreements
- A detailed budget and budget justification, up to $300,000 based on study design
Which types of organizations can respond?
Submissions are welcome from a variety of organizations, including districts, developers, researchers, nonprofit and for-profit organizations, and organizations that support stakeholders/organizations across the education ecosystem. Applicants should have a fully developed product that is ready for efficacy testing. All funded teams will be expected to pre-register their studies and publicly report findings, regardless of outcome.
Will I receive feedback on my response?
Reviewers from Digital Promise and the Gates Foundation are not able to provide individual feedback. The RFI will inform a broader analysis that we will publish based on what we learn across responses.
My organization has more than one product ready for efficacy testing. Can I submit more than one response?
Yes. You may submit multiple responses if you have distinct ideas, or one response that describes a multifaceted idea. All submissions will be read.
What are the five generative AI use cases?
In the RFI, you will be asked which of these use cases your product aligns with (you can select one or more):
- AI tutoring: Tools that simulate a one-on-one or small-group tutor, offering step-by-step guidance, explanations, hints, and encouragement; chat-based or multimodal, using voice and images as inputs.
- Adaptive practice and feedback: Tools that adjust the difficulty, sequence, and type of practice in real time based on student responses, providing instant feedback and personalizing trajectories toward mastery.
- Student work analysis and grading: Tools that automate evaluation of student work, from auto-scoring short answers to analyzing step-by-step reasoning, surfacing patterns and misconceptions that inform instruction.
- Lesson planning: Tools that generate or adapt lesson outlines, examples, activities, and assessments; align to standards; and personalize components based on student profiles.
- Professional learning and coaching: Tools that scale observation, feedback, and practice, such as analyzing classroom audio and video to deliver targeted feedback or creating low-stakes simulations where teachers rehearse skills.
Are organizations based outside the United States eligible?
Yes, organizations based outside of the U.S. are eligible to apply if all testing is U.S.-based.
Are early childhood or postsecondary products eligible?
Only products focused on K–12 will be considered. Product teams working on projects in grades K–3 are encouraged to apply.
Can data be collected at international schools if the respondent is based in the United States?
No. District and school partners should be U.S.-based and all testing should take place in the U.S.
Who can I contact with questions?
For questions, email the ENCORE team. We’ll add answers to common questions here throughout the RFI period.
Ready to Respond?
Submit your RFI response by Jan. 8, 2027. Questions? Email the ENCORE team.