Scaffolding Students

Before monitoring for equitable participation, students should also be scaffolded into understanding ways to participate in discussion. By providing students with support in engaging in discussion, this helps facilitate more equitable participation from the beginning. 

Sentence stems students can be provided with when engaging in a critical conversation:

“What did you mean when you mentioned … ?” 
“I agree and would add … ” 
“I agree when you say … but disagree when you say … ” 
“I disagree when you say … because …” (Learning for Justice, 2019, p. 24)

Another way to scaffold students is to encourage the use of hand signals to let students nonverbally participate or indicate how they’d like to participate. The video below (1:55) from Edutopia shows five hand signals teachers can introduce to students. Teachers can also build on this by using this video as a starting point and asking students to brainstorm hand signals they would like to incorporate during discussions. The hand signals are especially helpful for synchronous video discussions.

In addition, if students are reading texts ahead of time, scaffolding the text will also prepare students to engage in group discussion. Teachers can:

Provide a glossary
Add equity focused questions at the beginning of the reading 
Note stopping points for students to summarize and reflect on the text or themselves in relation to the text
Add guiding questions at the end of the text for further thinking