Getting Ahead of AI: Strategies to Foster Critical Thinking and Academic Integrity – Digital Promise

Getting Ahead of AI: Strategies to Foster Critical Thinking and Academic Integrity

photo of three teachers collaborating around a table
As artificial intelligence becomes an integral part of our educational system, schools must carefully balance the promotion of innovation with the necessity for responsible use. AI presents exciting opportunities to enhance learning, foster inquiry, and bolster student creativity; however, its integration requires thoughtful guidance. Educators, whether new to AI or seasoned users, need support to use AI responsibly and effectively. This includes coherent systems and policies that align with the district’s long-term vision, inclusive leadership that drives digital transformation, and ongoing professional learning to build digital competency. With these supports in place, teachers can explore AI’s potential while maintaining strong ethical and instructional standards.

This approach to responsible AI use aligns with Digital Promise’s Digital Equity Framework. The Powerful Learning Propelled by Technology domain emphasizes leveraging technology to create meaningful, rigorous, and relevant learning experiences. For AI to truly support powerful learning, it must be used intentionally to fuel critical thinking, collaboration, and authentic problem-solving.

This blog post highlights insights from a district leader, a school leader, and an instructional coach, each sharing strategies to help teachers utilize AI responsibly. These strategies include developing district-wide policies that encourage both exploration and caution, providing ongoing professional development, and being transparent with students on how to use AI critically. These perspectives underscore the importance of implementing AI thoughtfully in the classroom. By equipping educators with the right tools and mindset, schools can ensure that students are prepared not only to adapt to AI-driven changes but also to thrive within them.

Balance Curiosity with Caution: Insights from a District Leader

Katelyn Schoenhofer, Wichita Public Schools, KansasKatelyn Schoenhofer headshot

It’s important for me to help prepare teachers to guide learners responsibly and creatively in an AI-driven world, meeting them where they are. Whether they’re curious beginners, hesitant about change, or already comfortable with exploring generative AI tools, I know that ensuring everyone feels supported is key. I believe that having district policies in place that encourage exploration while maintaining clear ethical guidelines, like protecting confidential data, fact-checking outputs, and consistently modeling responsible AI practices is the best place to start. Rather than using AI simply as a shortcut for memorization or content generation, I see the value in ongoing district-wide professional development that focuses on redesigning learning experiences through the use or integration of AI. This approach fosters inquiry, critical thinking, and authentic problem-solving. Through individual coaching, building-level training, and collaborative classroom projects, I can help educators become empowered to use AI to guide students in taking ownership of their learning, all while developing skills that are increasingly relevant to industries transformed by AI. Ultimately, my goal is to balance curiosity with caution, ensuring that innovation aligns with the vision of preparing students to thrive, not just survive, in a changing world. I want to help educators proactively respond to shifts beyond education, ensuring that students develop the future-ready skills they need for success.

Supporting Teachers for Responsible AI: Insights from a School Leader

Erica Slobodnik, Duquesne City School District, Pennsylvania

Erica Slobodnik Headshot As a first-year principal, I am committed to supporting my teachers in using AI responsibly. It’s important for us to have a collaborative environment where teachers have access to the tools, training, and guidance they need to integrate AI in meaningful, ethical, and safe ways. With so many generative AI tools available for classroom use, I recognize my obligation to provide ongoing professional learning opportunities, and I am grateful to have a team of colleagues to support me in providing the types of professional development that my teachers need and want. As principal, I want all of our students to be engaged in personalized learning and to think critically, and I recognize the ways AI can support this; however, it’s my responsibility to support teachers in understanding how to select the right AI tools—tools that are safe for students, align with instructional goals, personalize learning, and promote critical thinking.

Be Transparent with Students: Insights from an Instructional Coach

Tera Phipps, Orange Public Schools, New JerseyTera Phipps headshot

Educators understand the importance of modeling the behaviors they expect from students. That’s why, when I recently collaborated with one of my English Language Arts (ELA) teachers on a lesson about identifying misinformation and bias, we made sure to practice what we preach. To make the lesson engaging and relevant, we used AI to generate multiple summary examples for an activity. But we didn’t stop there; we were transparent with students about the tools we used. We took the opportunity to show them how to credit AI-generated content appropriately, reinforcing ethical digital literacy skills. By integrating AI into the lesson in a thoughtful way, we not only helped students sharpen their critical thinking, but also gave them a real-world example of responsible AI use. If we want our students to be informed, ethical users of technology, it starts with us.

Preparing educators to integrate AI into the classroom responsibly requires a balanced approach that fosters curiosity while maintaining caution. School leaders play a crucial role in supporting teachers through ongoing professional development, ensuring they have the tools and guidance necessary to use AI ethically and effectively. Transparency with students is essential, as it not only models responsible behavior but also reinforces critical digital literacy skills. Ultimately, by equipping educators with the right resources and mindset, schools can cultivate a generation of students who are informed, ethical, and ready to navigate the challenges of an AI-driven world.

Learn more about AI literacy and our Digital Equity Framework.

Sign Up For Updates! Email icon

Sign up for updates!

×
Loading...