In October 2023, the Digital Promise Center for Inclusive Innovation, in collaboration with the League of Innovative Schools, hosted a gathering of over 250 school district leaders, educators, students, researchers, and thought leaders to discuss and showcase how critical authentic and intentional approaches to research and development (R&D) are to transforming education.
We selected five powerful quotes from countless insights that were shared at our national convening on transforming education R&D to highlight important perspectives and ideas that emerged.
“I have experience as a CODA—a child of deaf adults. I was the interpreter bridging the hearing and deaf worlds together. What I realized is that technology is that bridge. Technology is what allows all of us to connect, but even more so people with disabilities.”
- Heather Dowdy, Accessibility Catalyst and Leader, Director of Product Accessibility, Netflix
Heather Dowdy, an accessibility catalyst and leader, opened up with a powerful keynote centered on her story of being a child with parents who could not hear. Growing up as a “CODA” (child of deaf adults) and seeing the limitations created by an environment designed primarily for those who can hear led Heather to pursue engineering to shape technologies to make the world accessible to all. As a child, she had to bridge the hearing and deaf worlds—and now, she believes “technology is that bridge” that allows people with disabilities to connect.
Heather underscored how the pandemic made it abundantly clear that the number of people navigating life with disabilities is growing; the challenge is that only 1 in 10 people have access to the technology they need. She cited examples of promising disability-centered tech, including SignUp caption plugins created by a 17-year-old, Netflix-narrated audio tracks, NWEA assessments, and I-STEM. She closed by asking, “How are ALL the children?” as a call to action to meet the needs of not just some, but all.
“I personally know how it feels to not belong. So I want you to know that I matter [and] you matter, and with all the work we’re doing here today, everyone after us will be inspired.”
- Ray’Aunnah Tillis, College Freshman, Miami University and Middletown City School District Graduate
Seven high schoolers from the Digital Promise League of Innovative Students opened the convening by setting the stage for how students can lead education transformation. Over the past year, the students, supported by the Center for Inclusive Innovation research team, have led research to develop a student challenge map that outlines prevalent education challenges students face and ideas for solutions. The students conducted research with peers in their school districts to unearth what students both need and want in education. Topics included passion-driven classes, opportunities to partner with district administrators to improve education, better teacher-student relationships, refinements in student course selection, and more diverse curriculum. Most importantly, the students want adults to take their ideas for creating change seriously, as often their ideas are discarded or categorized as “nice to have.”
The value of student-led research is evident both in the ideas that emerge and in the array of durable skills they develop, including how to structure a research project, develop a research plan, create assessment tools, and conduct interviews and focus groups. The work encouraged the students to step out of their comfort zones. As noted by Madison Asperer of Rowland Unified School District, “I realized that the more information I absorbed, the more invested I became in finding the solutions. Now I find that I’m not afraid to question or be vulnerable with teachers or administration.”
Every student underscored the value of the role of teachers in encouraging and enabling students voice and leadership. “The real power comes from the confluence of students and adults,” shared Krisha Singhani of San Ramon Valley Unified School District.
“The agenda for R&D in education cannot be a top-down approach. We need to think about how we approach research and evidence-building in the field. Part of the theory of action is that we need to radically blur lines between practice, research and policymaking; we need to bring those much closer together.”
- Roberto Rodriguez, Assistant Secretary, Office of Planning, Evaluation and Policy, U.S. Department of Education
“If we pivot the discussion about why education is essential to the supply chain, all of a sudden we go from a little box over here to a giant box over there. We are never going to get the money we need to improve education if we keep thinking about education as a little box.”
- Dr. Mark Schneider, Director of the Institute of Education Sciences, U.S. Department of Education
Digital Promise President and CEO Jean-Claude Brizard hosted a timely discussion with Roberto Rodriguez and Dr. Mark Schneider on the federal R&D and policy landscape. The conversation centered on the New Essential Education Discoveries (NEED) Act, a bi-partisian effort to support R&D investment in a new center called the National Center for Advanced Development in Education (NCADE), to create advancements in teaching and learning through technology and innovation. Roberto Rodriguez shared an overview: “The NEED Act would authorize a new national center that points to the importance of R&D as part of a greater plan to usher in innovation and change in education.”
Ensuring students have access to the best learning experiences that are not derailed by pandemics and embody the best technologies requires prioritizing education as a significant national investment. Dr. Schneider underscored the importance of reducing the traditional education R&D timeline by engaging in “rapid-cycle research” that brings educators and students closer to the process and accelerates outcomes. He noted, “We need to get students the skills they need to compete in the job market.” The speakers invited the audience to connect with the Alliance for Learning Innovation, a coalition of organizations leading the effort to inform and advocate for building better R&D infrastructure in education.
“What I'm most concerned about with AI is that we make the same mistakes we made with the first wave of edtech. We didn’t spend enough time thinking about the mindset of the teacher. We didn’t spend enough time building the capacity of our educators to rethink learning. We need to create more space for the learner to be an empowered, self-directed agent. If that doesn't happen, AI will only become a cheating tool.”
- Jason Green, Co-Founder and CEO, Learning Innovation Catalyst (LINC)
Not surprisingly, AI was at the forefront of the minds and conversations at the convening. Our AI panel went “beyond the buzz” to discuss real applications, ideas, and concerns with AI in education. Jason Green with LINC, an organization focused on building teacher capacity with AI-empowered tools, underscored the importance of imagining AI as a partner to teachers and classrooms to enhance learning through collaboration and dialogue. Nicholas Gerter, with the student AI coalition Encode Justice, spoke to how transparency, literacy, policy, and implementation are key pillars to AI infrastructure. He encouraged educators to work with AI in creative ways, such as creating lessons on compare and contrast and inviting students to engage in oral defense on the distinction between the two. He noted how he uses AI to digest his course notes by having the AIsend him sample practice questions for learning preparation.
Nneka McGee, chief academic officer with San Benito Consolidated School District, shared the CRISP method that she uses to engage teachers to navigate their own fears with AI and technology: Challenge Conventions, Require Data, Identify Needs, Support Students, Provide Help. And, Heather Dowdy emphasized that “AI should never replace humans, but rather it should amplify human capabilities.”
“What are we doing to prepare our students to be global citizens, inclusive of all types of students and all types of learners?”
- Dr. Baron Davis, Senior Advisor, Digital Promise
“Education is too content heavy. Content is not as transferable as skills and abilities.”
- Dr. Michael Nagler, Superintendent, Mineola Union Free School District, League of Innovative Schools Advisory Chair
In a session centered on the World Economic Forum’s white paper, “Defining Education 4.0: A Taxonomy for the Future of Learning,” Dr. Baron Davis and Dr. Michael Nagler emphasized the criticality of inventing high school models that are mapped to the future, rather than the past—focused on developing the skills and abilities that prepare students for success in a global society. In considering how applying content can be directly aligned to the future of work, Dr. Nagler shared, “Content has a place, but it’s the application of the content. There’s a shift that has to happen here, from the content knowledge to the skill and application of applying that knowledge.”
At Synergy High School, Mineola’s newly designed high school, a curriculum was developed specifically to support students’ skill development with a dashboard to capture how students are working toward developing skills such as critical thinking, creativity and collaboration. By focusing on how knowledge is applied—as opposed to assessment only—the goal is to cultivate students with agency who are self-directed and will develop demonstrable, foundational skills to build their capacity to thrive in the future.
This was just a sample of what was shared at the convening. In early 2024, coinciding with the release of a new white paper, the Center for Inclusive Innovation will host virtual and in-person conversations and convenings to build on the momentum set in October 2023 to support districts, researchers and developers in advancing R&D with and for students and communities.
Stay connected to the Center for Inclusive Innovation by exploring our work, signing up for the Action Report newsletter, and following me on X (formerly Twitter) @k12kimsmith or LinkedIn for exciting opportunities in the new year.